Skip to main content

Silence in "Persuasion"

 In many of Jane Austen's novels, silence creates or at least perpetuates many conflicts between characters. In Persuasion, this is undeniably true. Sir Walter Elliot does not disclose his excessive spending until his family is forced to rent out Kellynch Hall. Had he been forthcoming with his lack of funds, changes could've been made to avoid that. Everyone is silent about how much they dislike Mary, which allows her to continue her insufferable behavior without a second thought. If Anne had not been silent about her strong feelings for Wentworth, they could have been together sooner. Each character is affected by what the others do or don't say, and only the reader can understand what those choices lead to.

If Mrs. Smith had stayed silent, Anne could have lost everything to Mr. Elliot. But, she eventually spoke up. Wentworth eventually spoke up about his feelings for Anne. If he hadn't, he could have ended up with Louisa or someone that wasn't even part of the story. There were so many opportunities for Wentworth and Anne to miss each other, especially after their initial breakup. Somehow, they find each other again and make it all right. But that's the magic of Austen. She shows you how many directions events could take depending on who decides to speak up or stand back. She emulates life in its perfect imperfection where the unpredictable nature of humanity constantly foils itself. Austen manipulates silence to show how powerful it can be even when it isn't acknowledged by the people it's affecting. 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Cotton-Eyed Bartleby

Herman Melville's "Bartleby the Scrivener" is secretly about Cotton-Eyed Joe. We often talk about how poems resemble songs, so why can't the plots of short stories do the same? In the case of "Bartleby", I think that he as a person can easily be likened to our dear old pal CE Joe. We don't know where he came from, we don't know where he went (in the biblical sense). He has an air of mystery about him. He messes with the narrator's personal life. I know that this is silly, but I think it's fun to relate things that you don't necessarily enjoy to things that you do. If anyone can think of other parallels between the two, please feel free to comment them below.
Post a Comment
Read more

Crickets and Kelp

This week in class, we discussed Kawabata's "The Grasshopper and the Bell Cricket". Last week, we discussed a poem about kelp. In both cases, relationships/people are compared to these mundane creatures. This begs the question: how do you know if you're a cricket or kelp? Essentially, a cricket is something truly special; it's the end all be all person that you've been searching for and are lucky to have. Kelp means you allow someone to take what they want from you, leave, and come back as they please. Basically, kelp=doormat. But, how do you know if you're being treated like this? How do you know when you're a kelp when you think that you've been giving yourself freely but you've really been "being gathered" in a way? And what if you spend all your life thinking you're a cricket but you're actually a grasshopper? Or vice versa? And which would be worse? What if you really are a cricket and you end up with a grasshopper that t...
Post a Comment
Read more

If Dr. Primrose had lived through the COVID-19 Pandemic...

 This is how I believe Dr. Primrose from The Vicar of Wakefield would have reacted to the COVID-19 pandemic. This year has by no means been agreeable for our family. My dearest children George, Olivia, and Sophia are quarantined in their respective homes and we are unable to see them. Lovely Arabella has unfortunately contracted the terrible virus, and she has been isolated so as not to affect the children. While I shall never wish ill will so serious as death upon another human, I am not entirely upset that Squire Thornhill has been affected as well; unlike Arabella, his situation looks to be quite possibly fatal. If the virus removes him from this world, my poor Olivia will be relieved of her current hardship of marriage. My two youngest are safe with my wife and I. While the hardships that we are enduring at present are quite difficult, I have no doubts that we shall escape this pandemic with a stronger appreciation for our vitalities and privileges. We shall overcome this yet!...
Post a Comment
Read more